Name: Sal & Al's Diner & Billy Boys Pizza
Price range: $$

Sal & Al's Diner & Billy Boys Pizza Information

Stepping into Sal & Al's Diner & Billy Boys Pizza at 2261 Cooper Foster Park Rd in Amherst, OH, immediately gives you that warm, classic diner vibe, where the hum of conversation mixes with the comforting aroma of fresh pizza and home-style cooking. The menu strikes a perfect balance between diner staples and specialty pizzas, giving both locals and visitors plenty of options, whether you're craving a hearty breakfast, a juicy burger, or one of their signature pies from Billy Boys Pizza. Many diners rave about the friendliness and attentiveness of the staff, who manage to keep service efficient even during the busiest weekend brunch hours, making it feel like everyone’s a regular. Portions here are generous without being overwhelming, so whether it’s a plate of loaded fries, a classic Reuben, or a pizza topped with all the favorites, you walk away feeling satisfied. The interior manages to stay cozy without feeling cramped, with retro touches that give it personality while maintaining a relaxed, approachable atmosphere. Regulars often mention the value for money, noting that the combination of quality ingredients and sizable servings makes it a dependable spot for both casual family dinners and impromptu meet-ups with friends. Weekend crowds can be lively, so calling ahead or arriving early ensures you snag a good table, though the quick turnover and friendly hosts usually make waiting a minor inconvenience. Drinks range from classic sodas to fresh coffee, complementing the food and rounding out a solid diner experience. What makes this place particularly memorable is how seamlessly it blends the comfort of traditional diner fare with the fun and indulgence of pizzeria specialties, creating a spot where you can enjoy breakfast at noon, grab a slice after work, or linger over a late-night meal. The combination of hearty comfort food, approachable prices, and a genuinely welcoming staff keeps people coming back, making Sal & Al's Diner & Billy Boys Pizza a standout destination in Amherst for anyone looking for a satisfying, no-fuss dining experience.

Business Info

What People's Say About Place

My first time dining here. I had the Syrian salad with the addition of gyro meat, chicken was another option. I enjoyed the salad. I was there with a small group. One ordered a BLT, one a pizza, one the perogies, and two the chicken paprikas. Everyone was happy with their meals. The service was good.

I have dined at Sal & Al’s a few times a year over the past decade. I was happy to stop in for lunch today and see that the menu is as diverse as ever. Service was friendly and attentive. We were promptly seated and informed that while all items are available, they were running low on pierogi, so if we were seeking those, we would need to get our order in to make our claim on the final portions. Pricing is fair. Portions are generous. Our meals were tasty. This was the cleanest I have ever seen the restaurant, no dust on the decor.

Had an excellent corned beef sandwich, house made corned beef. Also had a great roast beef sandwich there not long ago. Fries were really good. Server was very nice.

We've been aware of this little nook of a restaurant for quite some time and we always say, "We gotta try this place." Well today we stopped, and we were pleasantly surprised! I had the gyro salad and the hubster had the classic burger, but there are a multitude of menu items. My salad was SO fresh and yummy and the gyro meat was excellent. The croutons on top of the salad were actually small bits of flatbread that had been deep fried. Wow! Took half of the salad home! My hubby enjoyed every bit of his burger and we both agreed we would be back.

Went to Sal & Al's with some friends last week. We tried the deep dish pizza. By far, the BEST deep dish we've ever had. Their sauce is absolutely amazing. Our server, Melissa, was super attentive and fun. Will definitely request to be seated in her section again. And, if you have a sweet tooth, it is worth noting that the ice cream shop includes both sugar free & vegan options. The peanut butter overload did not disappoint.

I was initially going to a sandwich shop located in the same plaza. I just wanted something quick to take home. After waiting for far too long in that shop I walked out. Strolled down to Sal & Al's. They sat me quickly. Took my order just as fast. I had the Smashburger and fries. The price for a warm meal in a nice restaurant was about the same as I would have paid for a sub. I recommend this place!!!

Cute little place with an interesting selection of food. My kids loved their buttered noodles and I thoroughly enjoyed my meat pies.

Another great visit to Sal & Als never disappoints Food & Service were excellent i come from Akron and will keep coming. I had read some of the negative reviews and although no place is perfect some of the comments were extreme The Atmosphere is great and the restaurant is very clean Keep doing what you do so happy for you and your new adventure. See you soon!!

Sal & Al's Diner & Billy Boys Pizza